[Ecommerce] Re: [A2k] Patent quality : open source to help?

[rishab@dxm.org]

i tend to think this is a PR gimmick. if IBM bothered to improve the prior
art citation in its _own_ (usually very poorly documented) patent
applications, that would be a good start. if IBM won't do it for its own
patents, it's just a nice diversion to keep the PTO and others busy looking
at public prior art contributions, while IBM can keep filing for more crap
patents which the PTO would have even less time to examine.

Original Message:
-----------------
From: Peter Eckersley pde@cs.mu.OZ.AU
Date: Wed, 11 Jan 2006 13:56:09 +1100
To: michelle.childs@cptech.org, a2k@lists.essential.org,
ecommerce@lists.essential.org, rssutor@gmail.com
Subject: Re: [A2k] Patent quality : open source to help?


I hope that members of the free software community are going to be paid for
helping the US government to administer an inefficient and unnecessarily
burdensome arm of their patent system.  Free software developers are alread=
y
doing enough volunteer public service work!

On Tue, Jan 10, 2006 at 07:27:21AM -0500, Michelle Childs wrote:
>  <snip> The US Patent Office is to seek the help of the open source
> community in improving patent quality, and IBM is going to lend a hand to=
o
>
> The Patent Office is encouraging participation in all three initiatives
> and will hold a public meeting at its offices on 16 February.
>
> http://news.zdnet.co.uk/business/legal/0,39020651,39246274,00.htm
> IBM leads US patent pack
> Martin LaMonica
> CNET News.com
> January 10, 2006, 09:30 GMT
>
> The US Patent Office is to seek the help of the open source community in
> improving patent quality, and IBM is going to lend a hand too
>
> IBM is expected to announce on Tuesday that it won more US patents than
> any other company and that it will participate in three initiatives to
> improve patent quality.
>
> For the thirteenth consecutive year, IBM was awarded the most patents =97
> more than 2,900 =97 by the US Patent and Trademark Office, according to t=
he
> company.
>
> IBM is also expected to detail three multiparty efforts to increase revie=
w
> of patent applications, in part by tapping open source developers and
> collaborative software. Partners include the Patent Office and the Open
> Source Development Labs (OSDL), an industry consortium that launched a
> "patent commons" for open source communities in November 2005.
>
> The US patent system and the quality of patents are increasingly
> high-profile issues in the technology industry. Patents have been the
> source of several lawsuits and a number of intellectual-property licensin=
g
> firms have emerged.
>
> Although the contents of patent applications are public record and
> available to anyone, IBM has worked with the Patent Office to develop the
> Open Patent Review, a program to allow people, including academics and
> corporate technologists, to easily view the contents of filed patents and
> provide feedback to patent examiners.
>
> The system will be designed so people can sign up to receive email or RSS
> alerts about patent applications filed with certain criteria, according t=
o
> Bob Sutor, IBM's vice-president of standards and open source. IBM is also
> sponsoring a Community Patent Web site.
>
> In another effort, the OSDL is hosting a Web site called the Open Source
> Software as Prior Art project, which will be designed as a way to search
> through existing open source code. IBM, Novell, Red Hat and VA Software's
> SourceForge.net are participating.
>
> Sutor said he expects that open source developers will search the prior
> art system to find existing software and create a "tagging" mechanism for
> labeling and categorising code.
>
> In a statement, the Patent Office said it intends to work more closely
> with open source communities.
>
> "Collaboration between the Patent Office and the open source community
> builds on the momentum of the open source model," said John Doll,
> Commissioner for Patents at the Patent Office. "There is powerful logic i=
n
> tapping vast public resources to address the growing public interest in
> patent quality."
>
> IBM's Sutor said that growing interest in the patent system and emerging
> collaborative technologies make more rigorous reviews "extremely
> feasible".
>
> "There's a lot of practical interest and a lot of academic interest in th=
e
> patent system," Sutor said. "And I think the community is going to be
> extremely motivated to do [reviews]."
>
> The third initiative, the Patent Quality Index, calls for a system to ran=
k
> the quality of the patent application. IBM is supporting the work of
> University of Pennsylvania Professor R. Polk Wagner, who will direct the
> effort.
>
> The Patent Office is encouraging participation in all three initiatives
> and will hold a public meeting at its offices on 16 February.
>

--
Peter Eckersley
Department of Computer Science   &                  mailto:pde@cs.mu.oz.au
IP Research Institute of Australia             http://www.cs.mu.oz.au/~pde
The University of Melbourne
_______________________________________________
A2k mailing list
A2k@lists.essential.org
http://lists.essential.org/mailman/listinfo/a2k


--------------------------------------------------------------------
mail2web - Check your email from the web at
http://mail2web.com/ .