[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Melathion: you haven't heard the half of it yet
More on New York City's favorite spray:
Malathion Fact Sheet. Loretta Brenner. Journal
of Pesticide Reform, Volume 12, Number 4,
Winter 1992. Northwest Coalition for
Alternatives to Pesticides, Eugene, OR.
Malathion Fact Sheet
By Loretta Brenner
Malathion is one of the most widely used
organophosphate insecticides in the United States
and throughout the world. It is used to control
pests of agricultural crops, ornamentals,
greenhouses, livestock, stored grain, forests,
buildings, households, and gardens. Industrial,
commercial, and government applications constitute
most of the annual U.S. usage. These uses include
schools, hospitals, warehouses, eating
establishments, food processing plants, and wide
scale pest control or eradication programs.(1)
Contributing to its popularity is malathion's
relatively low acute mammalian toxicity. But like
DDT and other pesticides that have been found to
cause irreparable damage to human and environmental
health, malathion may pose a greater risk than the
product label would lead one to believe. Shown to
be mutagenic, a possible carcinogen, implicated in
vision loss, causing myriad negative health effects
in human and animal studies, damaging to nontarget
organisms, and containing highly toxic impurities,
malathion has a legacy of
serious problems.
*USES*
Malathion was first registered for use in the
United States in 1956, and 10 to 15 million pounds
of active ingredient are used annually based on
1990 and 1991 data.(2) American Cyanamid Co. was
the first manufacturer of malathion; now there are
at least 14 primary producers worldwide. The U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) lists 342
registrants (manufacturers and formulators), and
1218 products were registered as of 1987.(1)
Malathion is used in a wide variety of situations
to provide broad spectrum control of many insects
and mites, especially household pests, aphids,
spider mites, and scales. Malathion has also been
used extensively in eradication programs for
mosquitoes, grasshoppers, gypsy moths,
Mediterranean fruit flies, and other pests.
Malathion is sold under many trade names both alone
and in mixtures with other pesticides. Malathion is
applied in ground and aerial sprays, aerosols,
foggers, baits, paints, pet collars, animal dips,
animal dust bags, and cattle feed blocks.(1,3)
*EXPOSURE*
Malathion's widespread use makes potential for
human exposure high. The National Institute for
Occupational Safety and Health estimates that
between 20,000 and 100,000 workers are
occupationally exposed to malathion in the U. S.(4)
For example, grain elevator workers in Louisiana
were exposed to grain dust contaminated with 0.17
to 32 parts per million (ppm) of malathion.(5) In
another incident, office workers complained of
headaches and nausea after working in a room
adjacent to a pesticide storage shed for a mosquito
control program. Investigation showed that
malathion was still evaporating from a wall where a
pesticide spill had occurred five years earlier.(6)
In California, where physicians make mandatory
reports of pesticide-related illnesses, malathion
was the third most frequently
reported pesticide. Malathion caused five times
more occupational illnesses, per pound sold, than
did the average pesticide.(1) (These data are based
on reports collected between 1981 and 1985.)
Exposure due to drift and overspray can also be
problematic, as is well illustrated by several
examples. A homeowner adjacent to a school in
Arizona sprayed his garden with malathion. The
spray drifted into the school ventilation system
and caused nearly 300 elementary school children to
be hospitalized with headaches, nausea, and
breathing difficulties.(7) During the 1990 medfly
eradication spray program in California, two
baseball diamonds were sprayed while children's
games were in progress. Most of those present
reported
sumptoms, including headaches, sore throats,
irritated eyes, hives, rashes, and nausea.(8)
Exposure due to household use is also common. In
EPA's recent home and garden pesticide use survey,
malathion was the 22nd most commonly used home and
garden pesticide (out of 78 chemicals reported in
the survey).(9) Nearly 60 percent of the uses are
for roses, other ornamentals, and lawns, and 20
percent for food crops. Malathion was still
detectable in hand rinsings from a home gardener
seven days after spraying.(4)
*MODE OF ACTION*
Malathion is an organophosphate insecticide, one of
a class of pesticides that are highly toxic to
vertebrates and are chemically related to nerve
gases used during World War II.(10) Like all
organophosphate pesticides, malathion kills insects
and other animals, including humans, through its
effect on the nervous system. It inhibits an
enzyme, acetylcholinesterase (AChE), that breaks
down acetylcholine, a chemical essential in
transmitting nerve impulses across junctions
between nerves. Without functioning AChE,
acetylcholine accumulates, producing rapid
twitching of voluntary muscles, incoordination,
convulsions, paralysis, and ultimately death.(11)
Effects of AChE inhibition on nerve cells in the
brain appear to be particularly important.(12)
Malathion can also inhibit liver enzymes that
affect biological membrane function.(13)
The toxicity of malathion is compounded by its
metabolites and contaminants. Malaoxon, a
metabolite produced by the oxidation of malathion
in mammals, insects, plants, and in sunlight, is
the primary source of malathion's toxicity and is
40 times more acutely toxic than malathion.(14,15)
Over 11 chemical contaminants and analogues created
in the production process have been found in
technical malathion.(16,17) These chemicals can act
synergistically with malathion to potentiate
(increase) its toxicity. Some of these compounds
inhibit not only AChE,(18) but other enzymatic
systems in the liver that would typically detoxify
the contaminants.(15)
Malathion and malaoxon are more toxic to immature
than to adult rats, due to a slower rate of
inactivation of the insecticide in the livers of
immature animals.(14) Acute ToxicitySymptoms of
acute organophosphate poisoning in humans include
headaches, nausea, dizziness, salivation, tearing,
urination, diarrhea, convulsions, muscle weakness,
incoordination, abdominal cramps, blurred vision
and pupil constriction, slowed heart beat,
respiratory depression, paralysis, and coma.(19)
Other acute effects of malathion exposure include
skeletal muscle damage (after inhalation)(20)
and abnormal eye movement.(21) Inhalation of
malathion may be particularly hazardous.
In animal studies (rabbit and quail), inhalation of
malathion caused inhibition of AChE equivalent to
that caused by an oral dose 15 to 20 times
larger.(22) The acute oral LD50 of malathion (the
dose that kills 50 percent of a population of test
animals) varies between 1522 to 1945 milligrams per
kilogram of body weight (mg/kg) in rats.(1) If
humans are as sensitive, less than 5 ounces would
be fatal to a 70 kilogram human. Effects on skin
and eyes: Repeated exposure to malathion has caused
allergic responses in humans, guinea pigs, and
mice.(23,24) A single exposure to the skin of a 10
percent malathion solution induced contact
sensitization in almost half of human volunteer
subjects, and once sensitized, very weak dilutions
of malathion (1 ppm) would trigger skin
reactions.(23) Technical malathion is mildly
irritating to the eyes,(1) can cause temporary
visual disturbances,(25) and questions remain
regarding its ability to produce external eye
irritation.(25)
*SUBCHRONIC AND CHRONIC TOXICITY*
Physicians have described longer term effects of
malathion exposure in humans. For example, asphyxia
of a pesticide applicator under anesthesia during
an operation was associated with his exposure to
malathion.(26) An older man suffered acute kidney
failure after malathion exposure.(27) In laboratory
animals, malathion exposure has caused stomach
ulcers, testicular atrophy, chronic kidney
disease,(28) increased liver and kidney weights,
adverse gastrointestinal tract affects,(29) and
changes in the adrenal glands, liver, and blood
sugar levels.(30,31)
*CARCINOGENICITY*
Use of malathion by farmers in Iowa and Minnesota
has recently been linked to an increased risk of
one type of cancer, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.(32)
Risks of the disease were elevated for those
farmers who had ever handled malathion and
significantly elevated for farmers who used
malathion prior to 1965. Risks were greater for
those treating livestock than for those using
malathion on crops. In another study, similar
increased risks were found for Nebraska farmers
using malathion.(33)
A nationwide study of flour mill employees found a
significant excess risk of developing non-Hodgkin's
lymphoma among employees of flour mills.(34) The
risk rose with increased duration of work.
Malathion is commonly used in flour mills for
insect control.The National Cancer Institute (NCI)
has studied the carcinogenicity of malathion and
malaoxon in rats and mice. An independent review of
this study found benign and malignant tumors of the
endocrine glands, brain, liver, lung, and
blood.(28) Liver neoplasms were found in mice.(28)
An EPA toxicologist also found evidence of thyroid
tumors in rats and liver tumors in mice.(35) Dr.
Brian Dementi, another toxicologist with EPA,
concurred and "found that the NCI study indicates a
positive oncogenic response."(36) In reexamining
its original study, NCI found dose-dependent
increases in thyroid tumors in malaoxon-treated
rats, but no other evidence of carcinogenicity.(37)
Tumors of the adrenal glands and leukemia have also
been associated with malathion exposure and rats
exposed to malaoxon developed benign mammary gland
tumors.(1)
The cancer causing potential of malathion and its
metabolites has been the subject of controversy
since the early 1980s. In light of this, EPA has
requested three new cancer bioassays from American
Cyanamid.(25)
*MUTAGENICITY*
Malathion is mutagenic (causing genetic damage) in
human, animal, and bacteria cells. Frequencies of
chromosomal aberrations were significantly higher
in cotton field workers exposed to malathion and
other pesticides.(38,39) (The design of the study
did not permit conclusions about a specific
chemical.) Increased chromosome breaks and
aberrations occurred following acute malathion
human poisonings(40) and in human blood cells
exposed to malathion.(41,42) Malathion caused
sister-chromatid exchanges (exchanges of genetic
material within a pair of chromosomes) in human
blood cells(41-44) and fetal cells.(45) Malathion
has also caused mutations in laboratory animals,
including mice and hamsters,(46-49) and induced DNA
breakage in the bacteria Escherichia coli.(50)
In some cases malathion induced genetic damage at
doses far below acutely toxic levels (45,51) and
effects can be cumulative.(45) Birth DefectsIn
humans, maternal exposure to malathion during early
pregnancy possibly caused an almost total absence
of skeletal muscle in a developing fetus.(52) The
mother had repeatedly used a hair lotion containing
malathion for treatment of lice. In the San
Francisco Bay area, a two-year study examined the
relationship between aerial sprays of malathion for
medfly and the occurrence of congenital anomalies
and low birth weights. The researchers found no
definitive associations, but they also admit to
limitations in the data and analysis. However, they
did find positive associations between malathion
exposure in individual years and increases in ear
anomalies, bowing of leg bones, clubfoot, and other
deformities.(53)
Malathion has also been associated with birth
defects in domestic and laboratory animals. In
rabbits, malathion crosses the placenta and acts on
the central nervous system.(54) Injection of
malathion into the yolk sac of chicken eggs caused
reduced growth and weakening of a leg bone,(55)
increased production of insulin,(56) reduced chick
weights, reduced hatch, short legs, bleached down,
nerve damage two to six weeks after hatching,(57)
sparse plumage, limb shortening, growth reduction,
and beak defects.(58) Reproductive Effects
Juvenile male rats exposed to daily doses of
malathion
had decreased numbers of sperm-forming
cells.(59,60) In two rat teratology studies,
maternal exposure to malathion reduced pup weights,
increased the incidence of hemorrhagic spots on the
backs of pups, and decreased weight gain of the
mothers.(25) Doses of 50 and 100 mg/kg/day of
malathion caused pregnant rabbits to have reduced
maternal weight gain and greater increases of fetal
resorptions (dead fetuses absorbed into the mother,
not aborted); statistically significant increases
in maternal deaths occurred at all doses.(25) A two
generation study of male and female rats exposed to
malathion yielded offspring that weighed less than
the controls, and had increased susceptibility to
ring-tail disease.(61) In sheep, malathion exposure
of pregnant ewes resulted in an increase in aborted
fetuses, still births, low birth weight babies.
Longer duration and earlier initiation of malathion
exposure resulted in more severe problems.(62)
*EFFECTS ON VISION*
Between 1957 and 1971 Japanese school children
experienced a tremendous increase in cases of
myopia (nearsightedness), that correlated with the
increased use of organophosphate insecticides,
including malathion.(63) In 1969, 98 percent of the
children examined from Saku, an agricultural area
where malathion was regularly applied, had reduced
visual keenness. Other examples of what is now
called 'Saku disease' in both children and adults
were reported throughout Japan where
organophosphate pesticides were applied. In
California, a lawsuit is pending on behalf of a 15
year old boy who was declared legally blind after
being outside while helicopters were spraying
malathion. An ophthalmologist and a pesticide
expert both agree that the boy may have Saku
disease.(64)
*DIETARY EFFECTS*
Repeated exposures to malathion produce toxic
effects in the liver regardless of an animal's
nutritional status, but malnourished rats,
especially those on low protein diets, are more
susceptible to the negative effects of
malathion.(13,65-69) Malathion was two to three
times more acutely toxic to rats on a low protein
diet.(70) This is due, at least in part, to the
malnourished liver's decreased ability to detoxify
malathion. According to the researchers, '...people
sustaining on nutritionally inadequate diets may be
more prone to the toxic effects of these pesticides
as compared to those having nutritional
adequacy,'(69) and they advise assessing the
nutritional status of a community prior to
exposure.(69) Behavioral EffectsMalathion blocked
the ability of rats to learn to climb a pole when a
buzzer sounded.(71) Learning to avoid a cage that
gave rats electrical shocks, and the ability to
remember this behavior, was also impaired by
malathion.(72,73) In one study, this impairment
occurred within one hour after exposure without
significant inhibition of AChE activity.(73)
*IMMUNE SYSTEM EFFECTS*
Eradication programs for pests such as mosquitoes
and fruit flies expose thousands of people to
malathion applied in aerial applications. These
type of pesticide applications often provoke
complaints of allergic reactions and flu-like
symptoms.(8,25,74) In laboratory animals, oral
doses of purified malathion disrupted immune system
function in mice at levels far below the dose
required to cause cholinesterase inhibition.(75)
This work suggests that malathion can cause
sensitization and allergic reactions in humans and
animals.
Impurities present in technical malathion can
further disrupt immune system function.(76-78)
These immune system effects may have serious human
health implications. Stimulation of immune
responses may increase allergic reactions and also
cause tissue damage.(77,78) Immunosuppression may
enhance susceptibility of mammalian systems to
bacterial, viral, or parasitic infection or
possible increased tumor formation.(77) Changes in
immune system functions in animals exposed to
impurities in malathion may also trigger lung
damage.(79) Both malathion and the impurities in
malathion can directly affect one immune system
function that creates risks for individuals with
liver damage.(80)
*CONTAMINANTS AND ANALOGUES*
Technical formulations of malathion contain over 11
contaminants and analogues that increase the
toxicity of malathion.(16,17,81) These occur as a
result of the pesticide production process, and
their formation and concentration is affected by
secret 'inert' ingredients and pesticide storage
conditions.(16) These contaminants act to increase
the toxicity of technical malathion up to ten-
fold.(15,16) Although the concentration of
contaminants in commercial formulations is usually
less than five percent, environmental conditions
can increase the concentration during
storage.(16,17) In 1976, an epidemic of malathion
poisoning occurred among 7500 Pakistani spray
applicators. After hand spraying malathion to
control mosquitoes, five workers died and 2800
became ill due to exposure to the analogue
isomalathion in the pesticide.(82) Storage of
malathion at high temperatures increased its
toxicity by increasing the percentage of
isomalathion and other contaminants in the
product.(15,16,17,83-87) Other studies have shown
similar effects during storage. Malathion stored at
40C for six months was 33 percent more toxic to
mice than unstored malathion.(82) Exposure of
malathion to sunlight,(88) high relative humidity
during storage,(84) and formulation with certain
clays and surfactants, can increase contaminant
formation in malathion.(85,88)
Some contaminants directly inhibit AChE
activity,(18) and exposure to large doses causes
symptoms similar to organophosphate poisonings.(81)
At low doses (down to 15 mg/kg) some impurities
cause a characteristic 'delayed toxic' effect in
laboratory animals, with death occurring slowly
days or weeks after exposure.(87-89) In several
studies, rats appear normal except for weight loss
from the time of pesticide exposure up until the
time of death.(77,88-91) Other reported
complications from mammalian exposure to
contaminants or analogues include lung damage and
bacterial pneumonia,(80,91,92) liver damage,(92,93)
kidney damage,(91) and prolonged blood clotting
time.(93)
*SYNERGISTS*
The use of malathion in combination with other
pesticides can increase its toxicity to mammals.
These synergistic effects are important because
pesticides are often applied in combination rather
than alone. In rats single low doses of malathion
and carbaryl (a carbamate insecticide) increased
certain enzymes that are indicative of cellular
damage in the liver.(94) The same combination of
pesticides reduced the number of live fetuses in
pregnant rats and also reduced maternal weight
gain.(95) Combinations of malathion and endosulfan
(an organochlorine insecticide) are more toxic than
malathion alone because the combination interferes
with malathion detoxification.(96) Diazinon
(another organophosphate insecticide) was also
shown to potentiate the toxicity of malathion
causing greater inhibition of cholinesterase in
rats than malathion alone.(97)
*RESIDUES*
Based on U.S. Food and Drug Administration residue
analyses, malathion is the most commonly detected
pesticide in food products.(98) Malathion residues
were in 18 percent of the 936 food items tested,
indicative of its widespread use in many crops. It
is also commonly found in animal feeds. In 1988,
EPA estimated that children could be consuming
malathion residues 1133 percent in excess, and
adults 507 percent in excess, of the amount
currently determined not to cause adverse health
affects.1In produce, malathion tends to concentrate
in the peel,(99) and may not be readily removed by
washing in water alone.(100) Peeling, cooking, and
heat processing reduce residues.(99-101) In one
greenhouse study, malathion applied at recommended
rates was easily detected on plant surfaces up to 9
weeks after spraying.(102) Malathion residues
increased with storage time in treated wheat,
barley,(101,103) and rice.(104) Apparently, this
occurred because the malathion dust used to treat
the grain adheres to the grains' surface and was
absorbed over time.
*SECRET 'INERT' INGREDIENTS*
Formulated products of malathion, like all
pesticides, contain many compounds that are
classified as 'inert' ingredients and do not have
to be identified on the label. There is little
publicly available information about 'inerts' in
malathion. At least two formulations contain
xylenes(105,106) and xylene was present in a
formulation of malathion that resulted in a human
fatality.(106) Xylenes cause skin, eye, nose and
throat irritation; impaired memory; liver and
kidney damage; incoordination; dizziness; hearing
loss; and fetal death and decreased fetal weight
gain.(107)
*PERSISTENCE*
Water: Hydrolysis (break-up of the malathion
molecule by a chemical reaction with water) is a
major pathway of degradation of malathion in
aquatic systems, and increases with increasing
alkalinity(108) and temperatures.(109) Half-lives
in water range from 1.5 days(109) to 21 weeks.(4)
In one river, 30 percent of the initial malathion
was present after 30 days(110) Degradation by light
may compete with hydrolysis in certain waters.(4)
Microbial activity and interaction with sediments
may increase degradation and are important in
estuarine environments,(4,111) but high
concentrations of malathion are toxic to
microbes.(112) Soil: Malathion is degraded faster
in soil than in water.(113) Reported half-lives in
soil range from 24 hours to an average of 6 days,4
and rates increase with increased moisture and
decreasing acidity.(113) Hydrolysis and microbial
activity are both important degradation mechanisms,
with microbial activity predominating.(114)
Malaoxon has a half-life of five days in neutral
soils, but persists several days longer under
slightly acidic conditions.(115)
*GROUND AND SURFACE WATER CONTAMINATION*
Malathion does not have the chemical
characteristics that make it likely to contaminate
ground water, but it has been detected in wells in
Ontario (Canada),(116) California,(117)
Mississippi, and Idaho.(118). Unfortunately few
comprehensive ground water studies exist, so
information on the extent of malathion
contamination of ground water is sketchy. NCAP has
no reports indicating that testing for malathion's
metabolites and contaminants has been done.
Malathion has also been detected in surface waters.
In California, five of 28 county water systems
tested were contaminated with malathion(4) and
storm drains in Santa Clara County (where aerial
sprays of malathion had been used for eradication
programs) concentrated malathion and malaoxon,
eventually draining into San Francisco Bay.(119)
*CONTAMINATION OF AIR AND FOG*
Malathion was detected in 27 percent of the air
samples from 14 states in 1970, and in 21 percent
of air samples from 16 states in 1972.(4) In 1987,
researchers found that fog droplets in California's
Central Valley and in Maryland were concentrating,
moving, and depositing pesticides away from their
original source. Malathion and other
organophosphates were the most numerous
contaminants.(120,121) Malaoxon concentrations were
10 times higher than malathion in non-agricultural
areas and increased with increasing distance from
pesticide application sites.(120)
*SUMMARY*
Symptoms of acute malathion poisoning in humans
include dizziness, muscle twitching, excessive
salivation, and urination. Malaoxon,a metabolite,
has much greater acute toxicity than malathion
itself. Other contaminants and secret 'inert'
ingredients can increaseits toxicity. At least one
'inert,' xylene, is both acutely and chronically
toxic. Exposure of farmers and flour mill workers
to malathion is associated with increased risks of
one type of cancer, and both malathion and malaoxon
have caused benign and malignant tumors in
laboratory animals. Birth defects, reproductive
problems, and genetic damage have been associated
with malathion exposure in humans and animals.
Visual disorders, behavioral changes, learning
impairment, and skin sensitization may also be
triggered by malathion exposure. Low protein diets
increased malathion's toxicity in laboratory
animals, and may be a concern where malnourished
human populations are subjected to malathion
exposure. Immune system disruptions due to exposure
to malathion or contaminants may increase
susceptibility of mammalian systems to bacterial,
viral, or parasitic infection,and increased tumor
formation. Combinations of malathion with other
pesticides can increase toxic effects.
Malathion is the most commonly detected pesticide
in food products in the U.S. Over seven million
malathion products are used in homes, gardens, and
yards in the U.S. annually. Drift and aerial spray
eradication programs can expose children to levels
of malathion that can cause illness.Malathion has
been detected in ground and surface water, air, and
fog. Malathion is lethal to beneficial insects,
snails, microcrustaceans, fish, birds, amphibians,
and soil microorganisms. Sublethal exposure of
these species can cause a variety of behavioral and
physiological abnormalities.
*REFERENCES*
1. U.S. EPA. Office of Pesticides and Toxic
Substances. 1988. Guidance for the reregistration
of pesticide products containing malathion as the
active ingredient. Washington, D.C.
2. U. S. EPA. Office of Pesticides and Toxic
Substances. 1992. Pesticide industry sales and
usage: 1990 and 1991 market estimates. Washington,
D.C.
<snip>
120. Glotfelty, D.E., J.N. Seiber and L.A.
Liljedahl. 1987. Pesticides in fog. Nature.
325(12):602-605.
121. Schomburg, C.J., D.E. Glotfelty and J.N.
Seibur. 1991. Pesticide occurrence and distribution
in fog collected near Monterey, California.
Environ. Sci. Tech. 25(1): 155-160.
========================================================
This article was originally published in the
"Journal of Pesticide Reform", a quarterly magazine
published by the Northwest Coalition for
Alternatives to Pesticides (NCAP). NCAP is a
nonprofit, regional organization working in the
Pacific Northwest to provide information about
pesticide hazards and to promote alternatives to
pesticides. For information about becoming a member
of NCAP, or about NCAP's publications and
information services, please contact NCAP.
========================================================
| Northwest Coalition for Alternatives to Pesticides |
| P.O. Box 1393 Eugene, OR 97440 |
| Phone: (503) 344-5044 |
| email: ncap@igc.apc.org |
========================================================